Индикатор Shi Silvertrendsig Форекс

Just a short addition :

In Shi silver trend indicator the problem comes mainly from the direction of calculation (I say mainly since it has a problem of not cklearing buffers too, but that one is a minor one).

It is calculated from right to left which should not affect calculation in 99% of cases except when the loop depends on external (external to the loop) values. And Shi silver trend depends on external values : the UD variable. Since it is calculated from right to left UD variable contains future value not the past value of the state (it is similar to 3 ema crosses indicator or solar wind indicator in that way)

___________________________________

I think that this type of errors comes mainly from people that were used to or are converting code from Tradestation. In tradestation variables can be accessed and inherited backwards but tradestation makes sure that the calculation direction is always correct. Once when the direction is inverted (and metatrader allows it) problems happen (almost all errors of this type can be classified as this error)

Here is a comparison of "right to left" calculation (small dots) and "left to right" calculation (big dots) :

Hi Mladen,

I'm sounding like a broken record for asking for the following modifications, but could you please add the 'ForSymbol' and 'Invert' input options to your SSA of price - advanced histo.

Again, thank you for your time and effort.

-spotforex

SHI SilverTrendSig

mladen,

It would be great if you had time to correct it.

I really would appreciate.

thanks

regards,

Thanks!!

Awesome mladen!!

Everybody Thanks:)

Thanks Mladen

Hi mladen!!

Good morning mladen:)

I need 3 ADX revels on this indi.

Can adding this?

sorry my poor english :P

Mladen ,you may find this interesting it is one of historical volty method called Parkinson's Historical Volatility eunic-brussels.eu - Services & Tools -> Knowledge Base -> Education -> Understanding eunic-brussels.eu data .Thanks.

Would you care to elaborate a little, Biddick? Confirmation only or trade selection?

Valeo,

I believe volatility is very critical element for determining the '' value'' .

''Volatility is well known to be very difficult to estimate accurately.

A common and well-known way to estimate historical volatility of a financial instrument is by calculating the standard deviation of each period in the sample.

Parkinson formula, named after physicist Michael Parkinson, to estimate historical volatility of an underlying. Contrary to the standard deviation formula, which uses only the security close price in its calculation, the Parkinson formula uses the high and low prices but do not use the close price. No method is better than the other and each one has its advantages and disadvantages.

historical volatility using different methods :

Historical Close-to-Close volatility

Historical High Low Parkinson Volatility

Historical Garman Klass Volatility

Historical Garman Klass Volatility modified by Yang and Zhang

Historical Roger and Satchell Volatility

Historical Yang and Zhang Volatility

Trading With MATLAB: Historical Volatility

Yes you are right. It may be good system. I was also thinking about it.

But problem is the following:

this SHI_SilvertrendSig indicator is changing itself on historical data. Signals from this indicator are coming even earlier than zigzag and those signals may be changed anytime (the same with zigzag indicator).

We should have the main signal (or crossing) indicator and any other indicators may be just for the confirmation of the signal or some filter.

But SHI_SilvertrendSig indicator can not be this main signal indicator in the system.

I played with Ichimoku and BrainTrading_signal indicators to create some system and tested something and create template to trade. But I had too many indicators: more than 12 in one chart. It should be more simple.

Look at the image: I used this chart to trade for one week. 14 indicators in the chart! Really difficult. Because i wanted to get the right signal for sell and buy, I wanted to know exactly. And I received 14 indicators.

It should be more simple.

Yes you are right !

I tried trading yesterday, just using the SHI-Silvertrendsig only in 1H chart I go in when the signal come.I attch the result.

( TP= 10 to 20 pips SL: 30 )

indicator

Yes newdigitial this indicator changes alot more than zigzag demo tried and lossing trades zigzag is much reliable than this indicator

Here u go!

Run it on H1 chart - it will make 1 lot trades.

I didnt test it so u have to do it your self.

Hope this will help u.

Thanks a lot, for your help.

I will test it

The expert A. does not work ? I put it at my demo acc 2 days ago , nothink happen.

Yep, i forgot to tell u, that expert will not work after all, i discovered that yesterday - thats becouse SHI indicator doesnt refresh and he set dots with 1 shift and then change it - i try to trade with him but it was usless. If u want to u can try to write that indicator in loop with 30 count - if some dot will come in that loop then set the buy/sell lvl on that dot and next check that the bid price crossed that lvl. But i think that system will not be proftable after all.

Yes u r right the SHI indicator doesnt refresh, i have to refresh it manualy.

SHI_Silvertrend

Jacoba & Kalenzo:

I have been testing this SHI_Silvertrend indicator for a couple of days now, and have discovered the same thing, that it does not refresh, which is not good at all. But it looks great where the dots paint in, but does the future change the past here??

In other words, does this indicator(if refresh problem was fixed that is)change the location of coloured dots after they paint in the first time ??

And can the author or anyone fix this refresh problem ??